Why Market Selection Matters

Before diving into the details of finding and closing Subject-To deals, you need to make a crucial decision that will impact everything that follows: choosing the right market. While many investors skip this step and jump straight into looking for deals, savvy Subject-To investors understand that market selection can be the difference between consistent success and ongoing frustration.

Subject-To deals have unique characteristics that make market selection particularly important:

1. You're Committed to Fixed Payments

When you acquire a property through Subject-To, you're taking over the seller's existing mortgage payments. This creates a fixed financial obligation that continues regardless of market conditions:

Unlike wholesaling, where your involvement might last weeks, Subject-To deals involve long-term payment commitments
Unlike fix-and-flips, where you can adjust your exit price based on market conditions, your mortgage payment remains the same
Unlike creative financing with adjustable terms, you're locked into the original loan's payment schedule

In a poorly chosen market, these fixed payments can quickly become a burden if rental rates decline or vacancies increase.

2. You Need Both Cash Flow and Appreciation

Subject-To investing success requires finding the perfect balance between two critical factors:

Immediate Cash Flow: The property must generate sufficient rental income to cover the inherited mortgage payment plus expenses
Long-Term Appreciation: Since a major advantage of Subject-To is capturing future equity growth, the market must have solid appreciation potential

Many markets offer one of these factors but not both. Some markets have great cash flow but flat or declining property values. Others have strong appreciation but negative cash flow. The best Subject-To markets provide both.

3. You Need Sufficient Deal Volume

Subject-To deals require specific circumstances to be viable:

Motivated sellers with the right mortgage situations
Favorable loan terms (fixed-rate, reasonable interest, good remaining term)
Adequate equity position
Appropriate property condition

Some markets simply don't have enough potential deals with these characteristics to sustain a Subject-To investing business. You'll waste time and marketing dollars if you target areas with insufficient opportunity.

The Three Market Types for Subject-To Investing

Not all real estate markets are created equal when it comes to Subject-To investing. Understanding the three main market types will help you recognize where the best opportunities exist:

Type 1: Appreciation-Focused Markets

Characteristics:

Strong population and job growth
Limited housing supply relative to demand
Rapidly rising property values (often 7%+ annually)
Low affordability (high price-to-income ratios)
Often coastal or major metropolitan areas

Subject-To Potential:

Can create significant equity gains
Often challenging for cash flow (negative or break-even)
Competition for deals is typically fierce
Best for investors with cash reserves to cover potential negative cash flow

Type 2: Cash Flow-Focused Markets

Characteristics:

Stable or slowly growing population
Affordable housing relative to local incomes
Modest appreciation (2-4% annually)
Strong rental demand relative to property values
Often Midwest or smaller cities

Subject-To Potential:

Reliable monthly cash flow
Limited long-term equity growth
Usually less competition for deals
Good for investors focused on monthly income

Type 3: Balanced Markets (Ideal for Subject-To)

Characteristics:

Steady population and job growth (not explosive but consistent)
Moderate affordability (3-5× price-to-income ratio)
Sustainable appreciation (4-6% annually)
Healthy rent-to-price ratios (0.8-1.0%)
Often secondary growth cities

Subject-To Potential:

Provides both cash flow and appreciation
Sufficient deal volume with less competition
More forgiving of mistakes for newer investors
Offers multiple exit strategies

Why Even Small Market Selection Differences Matter

Even seemingly minor differences between markets can dramatically impact your Subject-To investing success:

Case Study: Tale of Two Markets

Investor: Michael R.

Market A:

Annual appreciation: 3%
Average rent-to-price ratio: 0.7%
Average Subject-To loan interest rate: 4.5%

Market B:

Annual appreciation: 5%
Average rent-to-price ratio: 0.9%
Average Subject-To loan interest rate: 3.5%

These differences might seem small, but over a 5-year holding period on a $200,000 property:

Market A Results:

Total appreciation: $31,562
Monthly cash flow: $83
Interest rate advantage: 0.5% below current rates
Total 5-year profit: $36,562

Market B Results:

Total appreciation: $55,256
Monthly cash flow: $283
Interest rate advantage: 1.5% below current rates
Total 5-year profit: $72,256

Difference: $35,694 more profit per property in Market B

This example shows how seemingly small market differences compound over time to create dramatically different outcomes. Choosing Market B over Market A would nearly double your returns with the same effort.

The Market Selection Trap Many Investors Fall Into

Many Subject-To investors make one of these common market selection mistakes:

Mistake #1: Investing Only in Your Local Market

While convenience is tempting, your local market might not be ideal for Subject-To investing. Successful investors go where the opportunities are, even if that means investing in other cities or states.

Mistake #2: Following the Crowd

Just because a market is "hot" doesn't mean it's good for Subject-To investing. Often, the most talked-about markets have too much competition and price points that don't work for cash-flowing Subject-To deals.

Mistake #3: Overthinking Without Action

Some investors get paralyzed trying to find the "perfect" market. Remember that a good market with action is better than a perfect market with analysis paralysis.

Mistake #4: Ignoring Rental Dynamics

Many investors focus exclusively on property values while neglecting rental market strength. With Subject-To, the monthly cash flow is your protection against changing market conditions.

Market selection is the foundation of Subject-To investing success. By understanding why it matters and what makes certain markets ideal for this strategy, you're already ahead of most investors who skip this critical step.

In our next lesson, we'll explore the specific economic indicators that help identify promising Subject-To markets, giving you practical tools to evaluate potential areas for your investing business.

Why Market Selection Matters

You must be logged in to access this course